Public Participation Isn’t the Problem. The Rules Are.

This blog post is based on an article forthcoming in the Stanford Environmental Law Journal.

I’ve been thinking about two questions since leaving the Biden administration to resume teaching in a law school: Can public participation be structured to accelerate the delivery of the things people need to live flourishing lives? If so, what changes do we need to make, and is it worth the trouble?

Public participation that helps build things may seem oxymoronic. Participation is often lumped together with other procedures that slow government down and lampooned as unrepresentative and obstructionist. On this telling, participation is a weapon of the wealthy and powerful to protect their economic interests and property values at the expense of the public. After all, those are the folks who can afford to take an afternoon off to attend a public meeting or hire a lawyer to draft comments. Industry groups, which zealously protect their own ability to participate, sometimes paint a similar picture of public participation as a weapon of well-funded environmental organizations and other special interest groups.

The Case for Participation

But that’s not the full story. While serving in the White House Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) and the Department of the Interior, I was involved in decisions improved by public input. I also spoke with a broad cross-section of people about the importance they place on the opportunity for meaningful involvement in decisions significantly affecting their lives and livelihoods.

These experiences, coupled with research endeavors, including co-authoring a study finding that participation often changes the options agencies consider and the analyses they conduct, convince me of two things: Public participation is an essential feature of how government agencies make decisions. And many of the rules that currently govern it ill-serve the public and the government.

Public participation is essential because agencies make consequential decisions with incomplete information, and the public knows things agencies don’t. Constructing homes that flood or dams that burst will not solve the housing crisis, advance a clean-energy future, or convince anyone that government works. Moreover, the task of governing often requires choices among competing possibilities, such as whether to fund a highway or a light rail project across the same ground and with the same funds. Agencies learn about what people want when they listen. While local views should not control agency decisions, if accelerating opposition to data centers teaches us anything, shutting the public out of decision making will breed cynicism, not trust.

Those aren’t just hypothetical benefits. For regulations CEQ finalized in 2024 to guide federal environmental review, public comments caught inconsistencies and ambiguities that we missed. When the agency previewed a tool to identify disadvantaged communities, commenters pointed out that the method for handling college towns inadvertently excluded genuinely low-income residents living near campus. Crowdsourcing via public participation enabled the agency to fix those problems before the regulation or the tool went into effect.

Public participation also gives expression to a deeply held American value that people have a fair opportunity to be heard when the government makes decisions that shape their lives. That value is reflected in our constitutional right to petition the government for redress of grievances and reinforced by decades of procedural justice research. By instantiating that value, public participation can build and maintain the public legitimacy of the government.

Where the Rules Go Wrong

But here is the problem. Many current rules governing public participation have little to do with informing the government or enhancing public legitimacy, and they are often co-opted by NIMBYs and special interests to delay, obstruct, and sow the seeds of litigation.

Take the public comment period, which federal agencies are generally required to provide before finalizing regulations or authorizing projects. On the one hand, providing an opportunity for any interested member of the public to file written comments with the agency creates a pathway for the agency to learn new things and for people to express views about the things that matter to them. But, because a judge might fault an agency for failing to respond to any comment the judge deems significant, opponents have every incentive to use the comment process as an opportunity to file extensive tangential data, exhaustive legal arguments, and abstruse hypotheticals. The goal of such comments is not to inform or persuade, but to delay, increase cost, and build a litigation record. Because agencies know that opponents file comments to lay litigation traps, they respond in kind. For its 2024 environmental review regulations, CEQ produced a 900-plus-page document responding line-by-line to each comment we received. That document consumed enormous staff time, informs nothing, and is impenetrable and alienating to the ordinary person.

The specter of litigation also chills agency staff from meaningfully engaging with the public, because anything they say that differs from the agency’s final decision might become grist for a lawsuit. So, it’s safer for government officials to remain unresponsive when hosting a public listening session, even if doing so leaves those who show up to speak wondering if they have been heard.

If participation helps agencies, why not simply let them decide when to seek it? Because agencies, like all of us, overestimate what they know. Because political appointees on short time horizons systematically undervalue process that career staff know is necessary. And because the temptation to assemble a tidy record free of inconvenient facts is real.

Four Reforms

Instead, we should reform the rules for public participation following a simple organizing principle: rules for participation should be judged by whether they inform agencies or build public legitimacy. If they do neither, they should go.

Here’s what that might look like at the federal level:

First, eliminate the obligation for agencies to respond to comments. It drives the arms race described above—delay, cost, litigation—without informing the government. Comments would still be in the administrative record, so agencies could not blinker themselves to inconvenient truths. If litigation occurs, let the agency respond to any comment relevant to it then—notwithstanding the rule the Supreme Court established in the 1943 SEC v. Chenery case that limited an agency’s defense of its decisions to the record before it at the time the decision was made.

Second, keep the comments agency officials make in public hearings, or other fora for engaging the public, out of the administrative record, so they cannot be a basis for finding that the agency’s decision is arbitrary and capricious. I have no illusion that legal risk is the only reason federal officials come across as indifferent bureaucrats. But such a rule would lay the groundwork for government officials to more meaningfully engage with the public by asking substantive questions or expressing preliminary thoughts and views, rather than sitting in fearful silence.

Third, make it easier for the public to find out about public participation opportunities by establishing a single government-wide portal, as regulations.gov already does for rulemaking.

Fourth, reform the Paperwork Reduction Act. It requires agencies to go through two rounds of public comment before they are able to ask even basic and standardized questions of the public—such as using an internet-based survey to gather feedback on options the agency is considering—making it prohibitively difficult for agencies to seek the type of input that may be most useful for making wise decisions.

Reforms like these would orient public participation toward the goals of informing agencies and enhancing public legitimacy. They would enable public participation to occur without the legalistic and drawn-out process it too often becomes and limit the gamesmanship and obstructionism that give public participation a bad name. They would preserve important opportunities for people to express their views to the government about the things that matter to them. And, in so doing, they would enable the government to act both more quickly and more wisely, accelerating the delivery of the things people need to live flourishing lives.

Author

  • Justin Pidot holds the Ashby Lohse Chair in Water & Natural Resources at the University of Arizona James E. Rogers College of Law, where he also co-directs the Environmental Law, Science and Policy Program. Professor Pidot’s teaching and scholarship focus on environmental and natural resources law, administrative law, and related fields. He is a co-author of Practicing Environmental Law, the first environmental law casebook to use a problems-based approach to the subject.

    During the Biden Administration, Professor Pidot served as General Counsel for the White House Council on Environmental Quality, a political appointment within the Executive Office of the President. He previously held a political appointment as the Deputy Solicitor for Land Resources at the Department of the Interior during the Obama Administration and served as an appellate lawyer in the Environment and Natural Resources Division of the U.S. Department of Justice, which he joined through the Attorney General’s Honors program.

    Before joining the faculty at the University of Arizona, Professor Pidot taught at the University of Denver Sturm College of Law. He also clerked for Judge Judith W. Rogers of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit and completed a fellowship at the Georgetown Environmental Law & Policy Institute.

    Professor Pidot received his J.D. with distinction from the Stanford Law School, where he was editor in chief of the Stanford Environmental Law Journal. He received his B.A. with high honors from Wesleyan University. He is an elected fellow of the American College of Environmental Lawyers.

Similar Posts